Who won the war of October 7?
Three years have passed since Hamas committed its October 7 atrocity, invading Israel in hopes of starting a war that it must inevitably lose while winning world opinion to its side. Toward this end, it built 600 miles of tunnels to hide its fighters, with particular attention to putting them under residences and hospitals, knowing that bombing them would horrify the world. Indeed, the first accusations of genocide were leveled on October 8, while the attack was still going on. That was the plan!
The United Nations had recognized a Palestinian state in 1988, though without a capital or specific borders, and 130 member countries established diplomatic relations with this phantom by October 2023. (Wikipedia puts the number at 157, but that includes 27 that voted No!) And after October 7, the Europeans piled in, notably countries that were antisemitic, woke, or worried about a Muslim minority: Ireland, Norway, Spain, Britain, and France. The leaders of Hamas, snug beneath their hospital, must have been pleased with themselves.
And of course they were ready with the genocide libel. Again, Wiki is little help: its main article on the subject is the accusation, presented as fact, and if you search instead for "allegations" you're directed to the more truthful belief that the attack was the atrocity, beginning with a note: "for [the] ongoing genocide by Israel in Gaza since 2023, see...." Well, that's now accepted by much if not most of the world. To me, it seems a hideous reversal of the truth. The first generally recognized genocide of the 20th century was Turkey's expulsion and murder of Armenians in 1915-17. The word itself was introduced in 1948 by Rafael Lemkin, a Polish (and Jewish) lawyer then teaching in the US, and was meant to define the massacre of 6 million of his co-religionists toward the end of the Second World War.
Now, in the 21st century, it's being thrown at the Jewish state, established in 1948 for those who'd fled the Holocaust or (increasingly these days) who fear another. And who can blame them?










